The Best Nontraditional Wedding Party Gifts (That People Will Actually Remember)
Weddings are a celebration of love—and not just romantic love. They’re about the community that surrounds and uplifts you. If you're searching for meaningful, nontraditional gifts for your wedding party that reflect the importance of these relationships, look no further. This guide covers unique, thoughtful ideas for friends, family, pets, helpers, and vendors—with a focus on sustainability, experiences, and shopping small.
Table of Contents:
For Friends
Your chosen family deserves more than monogrammed flasks or mass-produced robes. Here are gifts your wedding party friends will cherish.
1. Custom Experience Boxes
Give your bridal party a curated box of experiences: think a coffee cupping kit, virtual cocktail class, or at-home spa day.
Try: Something Splendid – personalized gift boxes from small brands.
2. Personalized Story Books
Use photos, quotes, and memories to create a “How We Became Friends” book.
Try: LoveBook – fully customizable and personal.
3. Handcrafted Friendship Jewelry
Opt for ethically made, artisan-crafted friendship pieces that reflect your bond.
Try: ABLE or Mejuri's sustainability collection.
4. One-of-a-Kind Art Commissions
Gift a custom portrait or illustration of a memory you share.
Try: Etsy – search for "custom best friend portrait" to find independent artists.
For Family
Family members (chosen or biological) play a unique role on your big day. Celebrate them with gifts that feel intentional and heartfelt.
1. A Recorded Message Album
Collect video messages from friends and loved ones, edit into a keepsake video.
Try: VidDay – easy-to-use and supports causes with each purchase.
2. Custom Recipe Book
Compile your family’s favorite recipes, including handwritten notes and wedding dishes.
Try: Heritage Cookbook – create heirloom-quality books.
3. A Legacy Plant or Tree
Gift a potted tree or perennial plant with a note that says, “Thank you for helping us grow.”
Try: The Sill or Arbor Day Foundation – both support sustainable planting.
Want a wedding that reflects your values?
Visit our Planning Services page to learn how we design weddings rooted in authenticity, sustainability, and meaningful community connections.
For Pets
Our four-legged companions deserve recognition too. Include them in your wedding celebration with these thoughtful ideas.
1. Custom Pet Portraits
Celebrate your pet’s role with a bespoke painting.
Try: Crown & Paw – humorous and heartfelt pet art.
2. Locally Made Treats or Toys
Shop from small-batch pet treat makers for something tasty and safe.
Try: Winnie Lou or Polkadog Bakery.
3. Adopt-a-Pet Donation in Their Honor
If your pet was adopted, honor their roots by donating to a shelter on their behalf.
Try: Best Friends Animal Society or a local rescue.
For Helpers
From the friend who wrangled place cards to the cousin who DJ'd the after-party, these “helpers” make the day smoother. Recognize them with sincere, personal touches. It doesn’t have to be expensive to be elevated.
1. Personalized Voice Notes or Letters
Record a short audio thank-you or write a note reflecting on what their help meant. Package with a small handmade item.
2. DIY Wellness Jars
Fill a mason jar with herbal tea sachets, handmade bath salts, or sleep spray.
Try: CottageWicks on Etsy – handmade aromatherapy and candles.
3. Thoughtful Local Gift Card or Date Night Package
Thank your helpers for their time and energy with a gift card to a favorite neighborhood spot—like a cozy café, indie bookstore, or a movie/dinner bundle for a relaxing night out.
Tip: Support businesses near your venue or theirs by choosing gift cards from local favorites via platforms like Support Local or in person.
For Vendors
Vendors often go above and beyond, especially small business owners. A thank-you gift can go a long way in showing appreciation and fostering long-term relationships.
1. Handwritten Reviews + Tip
The most valuable gift to a vendor? A glowing online review + a surprise tip.
2. Locally Sourced Treats or Coffee
Gift a box of locally made goods they can enjoy after your event.
Try: Mouth.com – artisan food boxes from indie makers.
3. Spa or Fine Dining Gift Card
A luxe way to say “thank you”—give your vendors a chance to unwind after the hustle. Whether it’s a massage or a fancy dinner out, it’s a gesture that speaks volumes.
Tip: Look for local spas or chef-led restaurants that offer digital gift cards, or try services like SpaFinder or Resy Gifts.
Final Thoughts
Nontraditional gifts don’t have to be complicated—they just have to be intentional. The best wedding party gifts honor relationships, support small businesses, and create lasting memories. Whether it’s a handmade item, an unforgettable experience, or a simple but sincere thank-you, giving with heart always wins.
Planning your wedding with purpose? Subscribe to the Tapestry newsletter for sustainable tips, relationship-first planning, and intentional celebration ideas.